Recipe Ratings & Reviews

Here's how our rating system works:

One Spoon= Not My Favorite Five Spoons= Outstanding!

Old-Fashioned Potato Salad

Overall user rating:    rating
4 visitors have rated this recipe.
  • Great flavor -- easy to prepare -- I like the sharp flavors and even my husband, who turns his nose up at every potato salad he sees, eats it and says he likes it. We don't have kids, but I am guessing that it isn't a very kid-friendly recipe with the coarse mixture of celery/onions/grainy mustard. I love it.

  • I thought this recipe was very good! I added hardboiled eggs to the mix - we loved it.

  • I liked it. I thought the potatoes had great flavor.

  • This recipe for Potato Salad was so acidic with the grainy mustard and red wine vinegar, that I had to add my Own ingrediens to make it edible. Did someone honestly try this recipe and think it was good??? Yuck!!!