Recipe Ratings & Reviews

Here's how our rating system works:

One Spoon= Not My Favorite Five Spoons= Outstanding!

Fresh Pumpkin Pie

Overall user rating:    rating
2 visitors have rated this recipe.
  • My whole family loved this pie. They declared it the best pumpkin pie ever. I made my old version (much more fattening and canned pumpkin) as well so we could do a taste test. I will never go back to canned pumpkin or fattening pumpkin pies. It was confusing at first, when I wasn't sure which size pumpkin I should use, but then I realized I needed approximately 16 oz of cooked, pureed pumpkin because that is the size canned pumpkin you need to create a pie.

  • Good recipe except after preparing the pumpkin, I believe you should have put the measurement (e.g. cups) this would be. A small pumpkin can be many different sizes and/or weights which would effect the outcome of the pie. Yes?